Tuesday, August 30, 2011

Tender Sweet Young Things

When I was young there was a record (black vinyl things with music on both sides) called Free to Be You and Me. This record was put together by some well meaning social reconstructionists ( Marlo Thomas, Alan Alda and others) to help change the world by changing the minds of children. Today I was reminded of one of the stories on that record that in my youth assured me that everything would be alright, truth would out, and people would value me because of what was in my heart and mind. The story was "Ladies First".
In this story the self-obsessed prima donna repeats her mantra "Ladies First, Ladies First"  to receive preferential treatment on the grounds that she is entitled to this treatment on the basis that she is a "Little Lady" and this get her eaten first by the tigers. Beautiful.
The message to me was clear. Phony roles and selfish behavior lead to being eaten by a tiger. As I was brought up for most of my life in a lesbian feminist household I really believed that people would judge me by my actions and my heart and that my appearance did not matter. I really believed that... can you imagine?
Forty years later I have gotten over the notion that femininity is a cop out sellout mind trip. I have struggled to accept my own feminine identity as something good. I enjoy being a woman, and enjoy attracting men with what ever feminine wiles I have managed to cultivate, but I still occasionally want the tiger to eat people.
Today in a literature class the question was raised: "Why do more women than men wear high heals?" I almost broke a tooth at some of the answers.
"Men can't wear high heals because their physical anatomy prevents it. (ex. their junk)" release the tiger.
"Women wear high heals to make themselves seem equal to men." that tiger, is he still hungry?
"Women wear high heals because their tiny slim feet look so cute in little tiny strappy shoes." We are going to need another tiger.
As I looked down at this last commenter's feet they were indeed freakishly small, about half the width of my own generous foot. If she had had her feet bound in Japanese foot binding style, she would have appeared to be walking on her ankles.Did she really believe all women have feet her size, or was she just struggling to put herself at the pinnacle of achievable femininity. Sitting next to her, I could not imagine that I did not disgust her with my big, wide feet. (I am however very hard to knock down.)
What scared me most was not so much the comments themselves, but the tunnel vision that these people viewed the world with. There are no drag queens, tall, or big footed women that were truly feminine. People still do not see beyond their need to assure themselves of their own sexual, gendered value. Sorry Marlow, Sorry Alan there are not enough tigers to go around. here is a link to the song story referred to in this post Free to be You and Me "Ladies First"

7 comments:

  1. I've always been heavily invested in the conflict between how I define my femininity and how the "outside world" defines it. All of my research has shown that they do not necessarily see eye-to-eye. It is our job to show that feminine does not mean stick-thin with teeny feet and long, flowing hair. This piece made me feel beautiful and appreciate that I am not alone in my struggle.

    ReplyDelete
  2. There's a lot going on in here. Well-said, and funny to boot.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This was very good. I liked the reference of the tiger eating people tied in throughout the essay. I think you have brought the subject of what it is to be feminine out into the light and I agree the world in general has a VERY narrow view on what that is. And might I say I have known a few drag queens (one of them being a larger lady) to be QUITE feminine.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I like how you described what a vinyl was, like some of us might not know about your antiquated music disks. Also, I just so happen to be an eye-witness to this particular event, and if you did manage to summon forth a past-life fictional tiger to devour the narrow minded, I wouldn't have stuck around for the whole class discussion.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Some interesting and provocative thoughts. Great blog!

    ReplyDelete
  6. oh my! I loved the humor here. The tiger was perfect and the thoughts that went through your head were priceless. I always find I'm commenting on other peoples comments in class. Most of them are ridiculous...this keeps class interesting for me.

    ReplyDelete
  7. In a more interesting world, no lesson would be complete without at least one good tiger attack.

    ReplyDelete